How Good of a Predictor are Virtual Meets? 3A Girls


Cassie Unruh and SkyView Academy outperformed their preseason projection by a bundle, even without the benefit of an ultra-competitive freshman class. Photo by Alan Versaw.

After this one, two more articles to go. Then we'll draw some more extensive conclusions about just how accurate virtual meets are at predicting the top state finishers.

For now, though, we pull up the train for a stop at 3A Girls.

3A Girls 2015 Virtual Meet Team Scoring as a Predictor of State Finish

Here is what the preseason virtual meet suggested about the assembled 3A Girls teams...


#TeamScore1234567
1Kent Denver School7936152431--
2Salida High School8525122244--
3Moffat County High School165717205863--
4Colorado Academy184421505356--
5Pagosa Springs High School1901635374359--
6Frontier Academy1951123325772--
7Estes Park High School298151678990--
8Alamosa High School3021839738191--
9Aspen High School3204752686984--
10Peak to Peak Charter School3208256677144--
11Eaton High School3543455838894--
12SkyView Academy381262940103183--


And, here is what the eventual top 12 looked like from state:

TEAM SCORES
PLACETEAMPOINTSSCORERSTIMES
1Salida High School506+7+8+10+19 (29+48)0:58 1-5 Split | 20:10 Avg
2Peak to Peak Charter School561+2+14+17+22 (26+44)2:19 1-5 Split | 19:59 Avg
3Kent Denver School1159+11+27+31+37 (73+88)1:33 1-5 Split | 20:52 Avg
4Alamosa High School13513+20+28+36+38 (70)1:15 1-5 Split | 21:09 Avg
5Colorado Academy1474+18+23+46+56 (77+98)2:42 1-5 Split | 21:14 Avg
6SkyView Academy1755+30+34+49+57 (78+110)2:34 1-5 Split | 21:29 Avg
7Moffat County High School17912+24+40+42+61 (125)2:16 1-5 Split | 21:32 Avg
8Eaton High School25015+35+52+53+95 (115)2:50 1-5 Split | 22:01 Avg
9Pagosa Springs High School27033+39+50+68+80 (96+114)1:31 1-5 Split | 22:13 Avg
10Frontier Academy29625+58+65+67+81 (106+120)1:47 1-5 Split | 22:25 Avg
11Basalt High School33332+71+72+76+82 (121+123)1:36 1-5 Split | 22:35 Avg
12St. Mary's Academy34421+59+75+90+99 (101+113)2:40 1-5 Split | 22:40 Avg


Preliminary Evaluation

Both Salida and Kent Denver finished very close to where they were supposed to have finished. Peak to Peak was the big change on the scene. Recall, though, that the Pumas brought in the best freshman class 3A has ever seen (and, yes, that includes a few strong TCA classes). There's no way a virtual meet of times from the previous season will ever account for roster additions of Quinn McConnell, Anna Shults, and Tiana Bradfield. 

Overall the 3A rankings seem more fluid between preseason virtual meet and state meet than other classifications we've looked at this far. Yet, still, the preseason virtual meet correctly identified 10 of the top 12 teams at the end of the season. 

We'll call 3A Girls very good on the forest but a little fuzzy on the trees.